Danish Signaling, Reduced Lineside Signaling

Updated 000224

Contents

Introduction
Signal Types
"Reduced" Signal Aspects and Indications
      "Stop" (Danish: "Stop")
      "Stop and Proceed" (Danish: "Stop og Ryk Frem")
      "Proceed" (Danish: "Kør")
      "Proceed Through" (Danish: "Kør Igennem")
      "No Passing" (Danish: "Forbikørsel Forbudt")
      "Pass with Caution" (Danish: "Forsigtig Forbikørsel Tilladt")
      "Pass" (Danish: "Forbikørsel Tilladt")
      "Canceled" (Danish: "Signalet Annulleret")
Reduced Lineside Signaling Usage
      Omitting Speed Signaling
      Omitting Advance Signaling
      "Proceed Through" in Platform Exit Signals
      Platform Exit Signals as Station Block Signals
      To or From Ordinary Signaling
Peculiarities
 
Comments to this document

Introduction

Reduced Lineside Signaling  was a signaling concept planned to be used on all new signal installations from the late 1990s and onwards. The basic idea of Reduced Lineside Signaling was to utilize the Danish mainline Automatic Train Control system's cab signaling to reduce the need for lineside signaling. Reduced Lineside Signaling roughly removed all speed and advance signaling, leaving only the "Stop" and "Proceed" aspects (red and green) in the main signals. Trains without ATC were to be run at a maximum of 80 km/h on the line and 40 km/h within station limits.

Reduced Lineside Signaling was to be introduced on the Copenhagen Airport Link, but be used in all future installations on lines with ATC. Following shortly after was the resignaling of the Århus station. The Reduced Lineside Signaling caused some debate, leading to Århus stations being converted to ordinary signals (a rather simple matter as the case was), except for two Exit Signals still being without advance signaling capability. On the Airport Link the debate lead to changes in operational rules, to lineside signs and markers, and to some extent also to the signals. It was then decided to start a research project on the signaling concept of the future, and to leave this one line as it was until the research project has come to a conclusion. The Airport Link is therefore to be considered a loner not to be repeated, and possibly to be changed within the next years.

Signal Types

Entry, Entry Block, Exit Block, Exit and Automatic Block Signals are a standardized 2-lamp type, only capable of displaying "Stop", "Stop and Proceed" and "Proceed", i.e. without facilities for speed signaling or advance signaling. Physically the signals deviate slightly from the modern standard type by having the lamps spaced slightly farther apart. The increased lamp spacing is entirely due to different components being used and has nothing to do with the Reduced Lineside Signaling as such.

Signal types are as on conventional signals marked by a plate on the signal mast. Entry Signals always carry a Station Name Sign. Exit Block Signals always carry a Reduced Speed Sign and Exit Signals for the right main track carry a Switch Limit Sign:

Platform Exit and Dwarf Signals are identical to regular signals. Platform Exit Signals always carry a Reduced Speed Sign on their mast:

"Reduced" Signal Aspects and Indications

The term Prescribed Speed as used below is the speed prescribed in the Employee Timetable (Danish equivalent: Tjenestekøreplanens Indledende Bemærkninger, TIB) or Track Bulletins (Danish Equivalent: La). Prescribed speed in the Employee Timetable is currently 60 km/h throughout the Øresund Line.

Trains with active cab signals may receive a more favorable indication than what lineside signals indicate. Cab signal will govern in such cases.

"Stop" (Danish: "Stop"

 Signal Type
Entry
Signal
Entry
Block
Signal
Platform
Exit
Signal
Exit
Block
Signal
Exit
Signal
Automatic
Block
Signal
 
  • Stop
X X X X X
X

"Stop and Proceed" (Danish: "Stop og Ryk Frem")

When the current operational rules for Reduced Lineside Signaling were written, it was decided that it was undesirable to have Entry and Entry Block Signals displaying "Stop and Proceed" without the upper yellow light (and thus not being clearly marked as Entry or Entry Block Signals). The "Stop and Proceed" aspect has therefore been blocked in these signals.
 
 Signal Type
Entry
Signal
Entry
Block
Signal
Platform
Exit
Signal
Exit
Block
Signal
Exit
Signal
Automatic
Block
Signal
 
N/A
N/A
  • Stop, then proceed with caution to next Main Signal
    X X X
X
  • Maximum speed 40 km/h (25 mph)
     X X  
 
  • Maximum speed 60 km/h (40 mph) - or less if so prescribed 
        X
X
  • Route cannot be guaranteed to be unoccupied
    X X  
 

"Proceed" (Danish: "Kør")

 Signal Type
Entry
Signal
Entry
Block
Signal
Platform
Exit
Signal
Exit
Block
Signal
Exit
Signal
Automatic
Block
Signal
 
  • Proceed to next Main Signal
    X a) X X X X
X
X X  X X X
X
  • Trains without active Cab Signal: Prepare to stop at next Main Signal
    X a)  X X X X
X
  • Trains without active Cab Signal: Maximum speed as prescribed 
X X X X X
X
a) Deviation from ordinary rules: Entry Signal without Speed Indicator may precede Entry Block Signal, so that  "Proceed" as shown means "Clear to Entry Block Signal only"

"Proceed Through" (Danish: "Kør Igennem")

 Signal Type
Entry
Signal
Entry
Block
Signal
Platform
Exit
Signal
Exit
Block
Signal
Exit
Signal
Automatic
Block
Signal
 
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
  • Proceed
    X    
 
     X    
 
  • Exit Block Signal (if any) and Exit Signal show "Proceed"
    X a)    
 
  • Trains without active Cab Signal: Maximum speed as prescribed 
    X    
 
a) Deviation from ordinary signaling rules: Exit Block Signal in traditional installations show "Proceed Through" in this situation.

"No Passing" (Danish: "Forbikørsel Forbudt")

Signal Type Platform
Exit
Signal
Dwarf
Signal
 
  • Stop
X
X

"Pass with Caution" (Danish: "Forsigtig Forbikørsel Tilladt")

Signal Type Platform
Exit
Signal
Dwarf
Signal
 
  • The signal may be passed with caution. The route may be occupied
X
X

"Pass" (Danish: "Forbikørsel Tilladt")

Signal Type Platform
Exit
Signal
Dwarf
Signal
 
  • The signal may be passed. The route is clear
X
X

"Canceled" (Danish: "Signalet Annulleret")

Signal Type Platform
Exit
Signal
Dwarf
Signal
 
  • Pretend the signal does not exist. The canceled signal is not in itself a permission to start switching
X
X

Reduced Lineside Signaling Usage

Omitting Speed Signaling

The omission of speed signaling means that trains without cab signals must proceed at the most restrictive speed of the possible routes from the signal. On the existing installation this means 60 km/h in most cases:

In station exit ends the lack of speed signaling is no different from traditional signaling.

Omitting Advance Signaling

Reduced Lineside Signaling features no advance signaling. A train without active ATC must always approach a Main Signal prepared to stop. The traditional rigid naming and interpretation of signal types has been carried on into the Reduced Lineside Signaling concept:

An exception to this rule is that Platform Exit Signals shows "Proceed Through" when a primary exit route past the Exit Signal is clear. The reason for this exception is technical, since the Platform Exit Signal ATC interface does not allow for easy omission of the "Proceed Through" aspect if reasonable functionality is to be retained:

"Proceed Through" in Platform Exit Signals

The use of the "Proceed Through" aspect in Platform Exit Signals is identical to similar uses in traditional signaling installations, though in the total context the "Proceed Through" aspect seems somewhat out of place and inconsistent with the Reduced Lineside Signaling concept. "Proceed Through" from a Platform Exit Signal indicates that a primary exit route has been set and that signals in the station exit end show "Proceed" or better, i.e. Platform Exit Signals show "Proceed Through", Exit Block and Exit signal shows "Proceed". The use of the "Proceed Through" aspect with the Exit Block Signal only at "Proceed" is inconsistent with ordinary signaling but has been permitted by special instructions:

In all other cases the Platform Exit Signal shows only "Proceed", i.e. in case of the exit route not being clear past the Exit Signal:

Or the exit route being a secondary route:

As with traditional signaling, several higher speed exit routes may be signaled identically by the "Proceed Through" aspect in the Platform Exit Signal:

Platform Exit Signals as Station Block Signals

The Copenhagen Airport station, Kastrup, features an unusual arrangement, in which Platform Exit Signals are used as independent "station block signals" when running between the platforms and the maintenance and cleaning facility:

The unusual use of the Platform Exit Signal means that a train may be signaled to proceed from one Platform Exit Signal to the next by the "Proceed" aspect:

In traditional Danish signaling the "Proceed" aspect from a Platform Exit Signal means that following Platform Exit Signals also show "Proceed" (or better), and that the first possible signal at "Stop" is the Exit or Exit Block Signal. The use of Platform Exit Signals as Station Block Signals is not in itself contradictory to ordinary signaling rules, only to the practice applied so far. Until a few years ago, however, the Nyborg ferry station featured a similar arrangement for trains traveling between the ferry platforms and the ordinary station platforms.

No advance signaling is given when traveling from Platform Exit Signal to Platform Exit Signal:

Only when the traditional conditions are fulfilled (clear past the Exit Signal) may the Platform Exit Signals show "Proceed Through":

To or From Ordinary Signaling

Transition between ordinary signaling and Reduced Lineside Signaling takes place at stations. The stations use ordinary signaling. The first "reduced" signal when traveling towards the Reduced Lineside Signaling is the station Exit Signal; the first ordinary signal coming back is the station Entry Signal:

Trains traveling towards the Reduced Lineside Signaling experiences ordinary signaling through the transition station. The Exit Signal, however, only shows "Proceed", as this is a "reduced" signal:

Trains leaving the Reduced Lineside Signaling sees the last Automatic Block Signal as the last "reduced" signal, as the transition station Entry Signal displays ordinary aspects:

Peculiarities

Reduced Lineside Signaling is really to be considered a peculiarity in itself.

[Back] [Home]
[Comments]